A vertical wine tasting compares one wine from one producer across several vintages, so the year is the only thing that changes. Kelham Vineyards’ Ascot and Barrel Reserve Nocturne is an ideal Napa wine for a vertical at home: the 2015, 2016, 2017 and 2019 use the same blend of 70% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Merlot and 10% Cabernet Franc, and the same 23 months in oak and 5 years in bottle. Decanter rates them 92 to 94 points. All four are in our Winery Spotlight on Monday, November 23.
What is a vertical wine tasting?
A vertical tasting lines up several vintages of the same wine from the same producer. A horizontal tasting does the opposite: one vintage from several producers. Because a vertical holds the grapes, vineyard sources and winemaking steady, the differences you taste come mostly from the growing season and from time in the bottle. It is the clearest way to learn how a single year shapes a wine.
Why Kelham’s Nocturne makes a clean vertical
Kelham Vineyards and Winery was founded in Oakville in spring 1998. Grower Rory Kelham, a longtime Napa Valley landowner, helped build it around one patient idea: instead of selling every vintage young, hold the wines back and let them age. That choice created a library that now spans 25 vintages.
Nocturne is a Bordeaux-style red blend from Napa Valley, and the recipe stays the same from year to year:
- Same blend: 70% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Merlot, 10% Cabernet Franc.
- Same aging: 23 months in oak, then 5 years resting in bottle before release.
- Released when ready: the 2015 in 2022, the 2016 in 2023, the 2017 in 2024 and the 2019 in 2026.
Same grapes, same recipe, same cellar time. When the wines taste different, you are tasting the year.
Napa vintage chart: 2015, 2016, 2017 and 2019 at a glance
| Vintage | Napa growing season | Nocturne in the glass | Decanter score |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | Early, dry, small crop | Most perfumed, red-fruited, softest | 92 Pts. |
| 2016 | Steady, ideal weather | Fullest and most structured | 94 Pts. |
| 2017 | Wet winter, then hail and a heat wave | Most savory and earthy | 94 Pts. |
| 2019 | Late spring, long and even summer | Brightest and freshest | 94 Pts. |
Decanter’s Jonathan Cristaldi reviewed all four in 2026 and gives each a suggested drinking window of 2026 to 2036.
2015 Napa vintage: the small, early year (Nocturne, 92 Pts. Decanter)

The season: Napa Valley Vintners reports a warm late winter and early spring that pushed the vines out early, then a cold May during bloom that led to a much smaller crop. The valley got about 75% of its normal rainfall, and harvest was one of the earliest on record, starting July 22.
In the glass: Decanter calls it “fragrant and red-fruited.” The winery notes describe rose petal, sweet spice, cherry, strawberry and raspberry, with cedar and earth on a medium-bodied finish. With more than ten years behind it, this is the softest and most perfumed of the four.
Pour it with: roast chicken, mushroom risotto or holiday ham.
2016 Napa vintage: the steady year (Nocturne, 94 Pts. Decanter)

The season: Napa Valley Vintners describes a year that “started early, saw ideal weather conditions throughout,” with a steady, mild July and August. The valley’s first significant fall rain arrived October 14.
In the glass: Decanter calls it “sumptuous from the outset,” full-bodied with ripe dark berries and blue fruit. The winery notes add brown spice, cedar, cocoa and a mineral finish, with tannins that have real power. This is the fullest and most structured of the four.
Pour it with: grilled ribeye or braised short ribs.
2017 Napa vintage: the year of extremes (Nocturne, 94 Pts. Decanter)

The season: abundant winter rain refilled reservoirs, and spring was cool and mild. Then came the swings: a June hail storm caused isolated damage, and a Labor Day weekend heat wave pushed harvest into high gear. Napa Valley Vintners reports that nearly 90% of the valley’s grapes were already picked when the October wildfires began.
In the glass: Decanter calls it “deeply savoury and richly flavoured,” with dark berries, brown spice, soy and an intense umami character over earthy loam. It is the most savory and earthy of the four. For another take on this vintage, see our story on Immortal Estate’s 2017 Napa Cabernet.
Pour it with: lamb, beef with mushrooms or aged cheeses.
2019 Napa vintage: the long, even year (Nocturne, 94 Pts. Decanter)

The season: ample winter rain soaked the soils, and a cooler, wetter spring delayed bud break and flowering by a few weeks compared with 2018. Napa Valley Vintners reports a long, warm summer with very few extreme heat events.
In the glass: Decanter calls it “bright and energetic,” with pure, crunchy red fruit and brown spice, firm chocolate-tinged tannins, orange peel and rose petal. A firm line of acidity keeps it fresh. It is the youngest and most lifted of the four.
Pour it with: steak frites, beef tenderloin or the Thanksgiving table. More ideas in our Thanksgiving wine pairing guide.
How to host a vertical wine tasting at home
- Open all four together. Give each bottle 30 to 60 minutes to breathe. A decanter helps the younger, firmer wines open up.
- Pour oldest to youngest, 2015 through 2019, so each glass builds in structure.
- Use the same glass shape and pour small servings, so you can go back and compare.
- Look for the year in each glass: the perfume of 2015, the power of 2016, the savory depth of 2017 and the brightness of 2019.
- Keep notes, and taste again after an hour to see how each glass opens up.
A four-bottle vertical also makes a memorable holiday gift for anyone who loves Napa Cabernet. Want to go further? Read about our Stags’ Leap Petit Verdot vertical or our look back at 20 years of Napa Cabernet discoveries.
Shop the Kelham Winery Spotlight: Monday, November 23 only
- Today’s Flash Price: $39.99 each (Comparable Price $125, 68% off)
- Buy 6, save even more: take $10 off every 6 bottles, applied automatically at checkout. Mix and match any vintages to build a 6-bottle vertical.
- Free shipping on orders of $60 or more.
The Flash Price is valid Monday 11/23 until 11:59 PM ET, while supplies last. After that, each wine returns to its Everyday WTSO Price of $49.99.
Frequently asked questions
What is a vertical wine tasting?
A vertical tasting compares several vintages of the same wine from the same producer, such as Kelham’s Nocturne from 2015, 2016, 2017 and 2019. Because the wine stays the same, the differences you taste come from each year’s growing season and the wine’s age.
What is the difference between a vertical and a horizontal tasting?
A vertical tasting is one wine across several vintages. A horizontal tasting is one vintage across several producers or wines, for example several 2019 Napa Cabernets side by side.
What grapes are in Ascot and Barrel Reserve Nocturne?
Nocturne is a Napa Valley red blend of 70% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Merlot and 10% Cabernet Franc. It spends 23 months in oak and 5 years in bottle before release.
Which Napa vintage is best: 2015, 2016, 2017 or 2019?
Decanter rates the 2016, 2017 and 2019 Nocturne at 94 points and the 2015 at 92. Choose by style: 2015 for perfume and softness, 2016 for power, 2017 for savory depth and 2019 for bright, fresh fruit.
How long will these wines age?
Decanter suggests drinking all four vintages from 2026 to 2036.
Was the 2017 Napa vintage affected by the wildfires?
Napa Valley Vintners reports that nearly 90% of the valley’s 2017 grapes were picked before the October wildfires began. A Labor Day weekend heat wave earlier in the season sped up harvest.
Where can I buy a Napa wine vertical online?
On Monday, November 23, WTSO’s Kelham Winery Spotlight offers all four Nocturne vintages (2015, 2016, 2017 and 2019) at $39.99 each, with $10 off every 6 bottles and free shipping on orders of $60 or more. Mix vintages to build your own 6-bottle vertical.
Want first word on our next Winery Spotlight? Sign up for WTSO text alerts at wtso.com/wine-text.

